Why Can’t Kmart Be Successful While Target and Walmart Thrive?


by Paul Leinwand and Cesare Mainardi

What drives some companies to succeed while others languish? Successful companies develop a system of a few truly unique capabilities that help them create differentiated value for their chosen customers.

Retailers provide many case studies in capabilities-driven success, one of the most compelling of which is the big discounter triad of Walmart, Target and Kmart. And in this fourth-quarter retail season, we thought it would be helpful to take a closer look at what really distinguishes these competitors because they provide valuable insight into the key components of a winning corporate strategy.

We believe that all successful companies — Walmart and Target included — know precisely how they provide value for customers. They make a deliberate choice about their "way to play" in the market, guided primarily by what those companies do uniquely well: their distinctive capabilities. We define capabilities not as "people capabilities," but as the interconnected people, knowledge, systems, tools and processes that create differentiated value.

They then select a set of products and services that best leverage those unique capabilities and optimally suit their chosen way to play. Most important, they avoid markets, products or services that require new or disparate capabilities, and thus threaten the company's focus.

Focus for us, therefore, is not about picking just one market, but rather about choosing one coherent way of competing. The true story about Walmart's and Target's success is that they have gone to great lengths to focus internally on building capabilities and product offerings that suit their way to play. Kmart, by contrast, has failed to develop a unique or differentiated way to play, and all that goes with it.

Let's take a closer look.

Walmart's success doesn't just stem from impressive logistics, aggressive vendor management and its position as a low-cost retailer. What really underlies Walmart's advantage is a coherent and differentiated approach to the market.

  • Their well-defined way to play focuses on "always low prices" for a wide range of consumer items, from food to prescriptions to electronics.
  • They support their low-cost way to play with an integrated system of capabilities, including: real estate acquisition; no frills store design; and superior supply chain management involving among others expert point-of-sale data analytics.
  • Their product and service mix is kept tightly aligned with their way to play and capabilities system: avoiding big-ticket items (e.g., furniture or large appliances) where it has no cost advantage, or where new service capabilities might be required. And it innovates constantly within its chosen constraints: e.g., tailoring product assortments to local trends.

Target caters to a similar "money-saving" market, but offers a very different value proposition, focuses on different capabilities and has a different product portfolio.

  • Target's way to play emphasizes design-forward apparel and home decor for image-conscious consumers. Everything from store layout to advertising to inventory conveys an eye for style.
  • Its capabilities system supports this way to play with image advertising, "mass prestige" sourcing (with the use of private brand and exclusive offerings), pricing, and the management of urban locations.
  • In product and service mix, Target is similar to Walmart in many ways, but Target satisfies the needs of its younger, image-conscious shoppers by stocking more furniture, clothing and exclusive designer merchandise than Walmart.

Kmart, the least successful of the group, is struggling to define its way to play, describing itself as a "mass merchandising company that offers customers quality products through a portfolio of exclusive brands and labels." Yet, that definition could describe just about any retailer. As a Walmart customer, you know you'll save money and still feel welcome. At Target, you know you'll get fashionable products at prices that feel reasonable. What, then, is Kmart's niche?

Walk through a Kmart store and you'll discover designers like Jaclyn Smith in the low-budget ambience of a warehouse. They carry Kenmore appliances, which may require high-touch sales assistance that many Sears customers expect and many Kmart stores lack. In short, Kmart has not established an identifiable way to play that reflects both customers' needs and its own capabilities. Harry Cunningham, the founder of Kmart, allegedly admitted that Sam Walton (the founder of Walmart) "not only copied our concepts, he strengthened them."

The lack of a clear concept about how to reach the market, in our view, is the single most important factor in explaining why Kmart's fortunes have fallen so far, compared to its two rivals. Without a clear way to play, and capabilities to support it, a company cannot achieve the coherence it needs to truly excel at what it does, and thus outpace competitors.

Paul Leinwand is a Partner in Booz & Company's global consumer, media, and retail practice. He serves as chair of the firm's Knowledge and Marketing Advisory Council. Cesare Mainardi is Managing Director of Booz & Company's North American business and is a member of the firm's Executive Committee. They are co-authors of The Essential Advantage: How to Win with a Capabilities-Driven Strategy, published by Harvard Business Review Press.

Permalink | http://bit.ly/gHhz4H

134 thoughts on “Why Can’t Kmart Be Successful While Target and Walmart Thrive?

  1. Pingback: irish jeweller

  2. Pingback: download free

  3. Pingback: apk downloads

  4. Pingback: kimim ben

  5. Pingback: financial fraud

  6. Pingback: Skrota bilen Göteborg

  7. Pingback: Skrota bilen

  8. Pingback: trump for children

  9. Pingback: Skrota bilen Göteborg

  10. Pingback: drainage

  11. Pingback: VA Home Loans

  12. Pingback: click here

  13. Pingback: methyltestosterone sale

  14. Pingback: decaplex 300

  15. Pingback: Fabled CEO

  16. Pingback: clicker games list

  17. Pingback: subway surfers play

  18. Pingback: masteroxyl 200 online

  19. Pingback: Dicito

  20. Pingback: playboy casino

  21. Pingback: http://www.scoop.it/t/gagner-un-iphone-5s-gratuit

  22. Pingback: ICQ Chat

  23. Pingback: economics tuition

  24. Pingback: injectable anabolic androgenic steroid

  25. Pingback: photography business cards

  26. Pingback: More Help

  27. Pingback: read

  28. Pingback: social media password cracker

  29. Pingback: what is motor club america about

  30. Pingback: Best Best Online News

  31. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  32. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  33. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  34. Pingback: Switch Energy Supplier

  35. Pingback: Best Online News

  36. Pingback: TS Escorts

  37. Pingback: patagonia outlet locations

  38. Pingback: Jack Wolfskin Jackets Outlet

  39. Pingback: mammut store locator

  40. Pingback: ugg boots on sale

  41. Pingback: lead generation service

  42. Pingback: where to buy oakley eyeglasses

  43. Pingback: merrell shoes store

  44. Pingback: cheap adidas sale

  45. Pingback: merrell sandals outlet

  46. Pingback: hermes formation

  47. Pingback: cheap louis vuitton

  48. Pingback: emu shoes sale

  49. Pingback: hunter boats for sale

  50. Pingback: emu sale boots

  51. Pingback: sac hermes kelly

  52. Pingback: chanel department store

  53. Pingback: coach purse outlet online

  54. Pingback: callaway apparel outlet

  55. Pingback: marmot alpinist jacket sale

  56. Pingback: chanel jewelry outlet

  57. Pingback: canada goose jackets outlet

  58. Pingback: michael kors outlet store

  59. Pingback: five finger toe shoes cheap

  60. Pingback: prix sac kelly hermes

  61. Pingback: occhiali sci oakley

  62. Pingback: iowa fake id

  63. Pingback: modelli occhiali ray ban da sole

  64. Pingback: Un paio di occhiali da sole ray ban

  65. Pingback: id card fake

  66. Pingback: patagonia nano sale

  67. Pingback: cheap Henri Lloyd

  68. Pingback: ito Ufficiale Ray-Ban Italia

  69. Pingback: ray ban occhiali da sole a goccia

  70. Pingback: north face for cheap

  71. Pingback: valentino outlet italy

  72. Pingback: patagonia jackets stores

  73. Pingback: cheap new balance shoes

  74. Pingback: hermes ceinture

  75. Pingback: parfum equipage hermes

  76. Pingback: mammut outlet schweiz

  77. Pingback: florida fake id

  78. Pingback: fake id usa

  79. Pingback: arcteryx shoes sale

  80. Pingback: chanel e store

  81. Pingback: Ugg Outlet Online

  82. Pingback: fake id

  83. Pingback: stores that sell canada goose jackets

  84. Pingback: Pierre Hardy on sale

  85. Pingback: coach bags outlet online

  86. Pingback: hermes london store

  87. Pingback: valentino outlet online

  88. Pingback: canada goose online canada

  89. Pingback: parajumpers gobi jacket

  90. Pingback: callaway xr clubs for sale

  91. Pingback: keen shoes online

  92. Pingback: used callaway golf clubs for sale

  93. Pingback: real fake id uk

  94. Pingback: Indianapolis fake id

  95. Pingback: nfl week 2 betting lines

  96. Pingback: ray ban uk cheap

  97. Pingback: cheap ray bans sunglasses outlet

  98. Pingback: cheap ray ban outlet

  99. Pingback: cheap ray ban sunglasses outlet

  100. Pingback: cheap ray ban sunglasses outlet

  101. Pingback: fake id nyc

  102. Pingback: fake Mississippi can

  103. Pingback: cheap fake id

  104. Pingback: fake id for sale

  105. Pingback: places to get fake ids

  106. Pingback: nsw age proof card

  107. Pingback: Air max pas cher

  108. Pingback: cheap oakley radar path sunglasses

  109. Pingback: us id

  110. Pingback: fake id website

  111. Pingback: fake Georgia id

  112. Pingback: fake Massachusetts id card

  113. Pingback: Virginia fake id laws

  114. Pingback: fake id Mississippi

  115. Pingback: ray bans cheap

  116. Pingback: ultimate fake id guide

  117. Pingback: buy Massachusetts fake id

  118. Pingback: fake id picture examples

  119. Pingback: golden goose sneakers

  120. Pingback: hermes bracelet

  121. Pingback: Glenisland Anglers Co

  122. Pingback: golden goose basket

  123. Pingback: boutique hermes en ligne france

  124. Pingback: golden goose femme

  125. Pingback: ceinture hermes femme

  126. Pingback: hermes montre femme

  127. Pingback: chaussure golden goose

  128. Pingback: caleche hermes parfum

  129. Pingback: golden goose deluxe brand

  130. Pingback: hermes terre des hommes parfum

  131. Pingback: baskets golden goose

  132. Pingback: golden goose deluxe brand

  133. Pingback: golden goose soldes

  134. Pingback: belami hermes

Leave a Reply