Skype Away: Online Therapy is Still Exciting!

By John M. Grohol, PsyD

http://g.psychcentral.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/skype-away-online-therapy.jpg

It must be a slow news week, as The New York Times ran another article extolling the virtues of online therapy, with a focus on videoconferencing and Skype. In a well-crafted article, Jan Hoffman gets quotes from a half dozen or so professionals to demonstrate how online therapy (or e-therapy) is on a roll.

But like most articles on this topic, the reporter does the easy legwork — talking to experts in the field — but seemingly doesn’t ask any serious questions. It’s a puff piece wrapped in beautifully baked fantasy-land pastry.

So what’s new? Let’s find out.

Apparently what’s new this go-around is the anecdotal surge of videoconferencing and Skype. There’s zero data in the article to suggest this is actually the case, but that was the focus of this article.

But it’s so cool! You can lounge at your friend’s pool while drinking an alcoholic beverage and have a “therapy” session:

She mixed herself a mojito, added a sprig of mint, put on her sunglasses and headed outside to her friend’s pool. Settling into a lounge chair, she tapped the Skype app on her phone. Hundreds of miles away, her face popped up on her therapist’s computer monitor; he smiled back on her phone’s screen.

She took a sip of her cocktail. The session began. […]

“I can have a Skype therapy session with my morning coffee or before a night on the town with the girls. I can take a break from shopping for a session.”

While I have no idea the kinds of problems Ms. Weinblatt is seeing a therapist for, I don’t think they are the same kinds of problems that many people seek therapy for. How many people would be comfortable delving into their childhood abuse or deep, dark depression while lounging at your friend’s pool?

But while the example given is a bit over the top, the reason Ms. Weinblatt sought out online therapy is a very real and legitimate one:

Ms. Weinblatt came to the approach through geographical necessity. When her therapist moved, she was apprehensive about transferring to the other psychologist in her small town, who would certainly know her prominent ex-boyfriend. So her therapist referred her to another doctor, whose practice was a day’s drive away. But he was willing to use Skype with long-distance patients. She was game.

So there’s the catch… Videoconferencing is cool and all, but it utilizes only one of the benefits of remote counseling — taking geography out of the equation. Everything else about the therapy session is the same — the need to jointly schedule a convenient time for both parties, the amount the session will cost (sometimes even more!), lack of anonymity (if one so chooses), and the awkwardness of talking to someone face-to-face about deeply personal, emotional concerns.

Instead, the reporter focuses on some of the little technical details of doing videoconferencing well. Oh, the picture can be pixelated on bad connections. You have to know something about white contrast, and know to look at the camera when speaking. These aren’t the real problems with videoconferencing for psychotherapy.

The real problem is simply one of whether the way most people use videoconferencing today for therapy in any way approaches the professional emotional intimacy or therapeutic rapport of a face-to-face session. I would argue it does not, and that most professionals are substituting the idea of intimacy — because both face-to-face and videoconferencing show you a person’s face — with actual therapeutic rapport.

I’m not alone in this observation:

Johanna Herwitz, a Manhattan psychologist, tried Skype to augment face-to-face therapy. “It creates this perverse lower version of intimacy,” she said. “Skype doesn’t therapeutically disinhibit patients so that they let down their guard and take emotional risks. I’ve decided not to do it anymore.”

Indeed, perversely, online therapy done through videoconferencing actually removes one of the benefits of online therapy — increased disinhibition — and replaces it with a handicapped view of nonverbal behavior (someone’s disconnected head). Is viewing a 4 inch video of your therapist’s face on your mobile phone the same as sitting in a room with that person? Does it even come close?

What the article fails to talk about are some pretty important things. Like the fact that nobody has certified Skype for HIPAA compliance — meaning that it doesn’t currently qualify as a technology that one should be using for private and confidential mental health exchanges. To me, that’s a pretty big oversight, since if most patients knew that, they might be wary using it to talk to their therapist.

The other is the lack of any information about whether people are turning to online therapy more or less than they did, say, 5 years ago. Instead, we have this gushing anecdotal proclamation from a psychologist/lawyer:

“In three years, this will take off like a rocket,” said Eric A. Harris, a lawyer and psychologist who consults with the American Psychological Association Insurance Trust. “Everyone will have real-time audiovisual availability.”

Really? That’s an astounding statement to make, considering online therapy has been around for 16+ years now, and videoconferencing for online therapy has been around for over a decade. So during the next 3 years, everything’s going to change. I can’t wait!

The only data point offered is one I’ve seen time and time again — the number of therapists who sign up to offer this kind of service. In 2001, the online therapy clinic I ran had something like 1,000 therapists signed up at its peak. A clinic today touts its 900 professionals number. To me, that suggests little has changed — professionals are always willing to sign-up to potentially use a service (since it costs nothing to do so). But will consumers follow?

While we’re seeing increased interest in some online services from consumers over the past few years, it’s still a drop in the bucket of psychotherapy services. Most consumers who turn to videoconferencing online therapy do so because they have a specific need — one which is usually constrained by geography.

That’s a big market.

But the even bigger market is for people who value all of the benefits of online therapy that videoconferencing can’t offer. These include: not having to schedule an appointment time every week, feeling more able and relaxed to talk about difficult issues because of the disinhibitory effects of online communication, decreased cost (because you’re not taking up 50 minutes of the therapist’s time), and portability to take your therapist on the go without having to worry about sketchy videoconferencing connections.

After all, writers for thousands of years have transformed the written word to communicate immense emotion. While not all of us are Shakespeare, we’ve seemed to do just fine expressing ourselves through this written word online through our social media sites like Facebook and Twitter.

Surely videoconferencing has a place in online therapy, just as it has had for the past decade. But it creates as many problems as it solves (conducting psychotherapy in public places like a friend’s pool or the shopping mall?), and is unable to deliver on some of online therapy’s most important benefits.

Permalink | bit.ly/p8Dh0Z

162 thoughts on “Skype Away: Online Therapy is Still Exciting!

  1. Pingback: relocating to the uk

  2. Pingback: android apps

  3. Pingback: apk downloads

  4. Pingback: kid fights at school

  5. Pingback: EuroBolic.to - Anavar, Winstrol

  6. Pingback: Skrota bilen

  7. Pingback: child abuse

  8. Pingback: Skrota bilen Göteborg

  9. Pingback: basement waterproofing

  10. Pingback: bad credit home loans

  11. Pingback: Office-experts.info

  12. Pingback: business directory Emirates

  13. Pingback: digitürk

  14. Pingback: geofman

  15. Pingback: Silicon valley CEO

  16. Pingback: button clicker game

  17. Pingback: hampton bay light kit

  18. Pingback: best whatsapp status in hindi

  19. Pingback: click here to find an attorney

  20. Pingback: Firstrow

  21. Pingback: scr888 slot malaysia

  22. Pingback: whatsapp spy android free download

  23. Pingback: review

  24. Pingback: econs tuition

  25. Pingback: audio visual services detroit

  26. Pingback: Read This

  27. Pingback: I loved this

  28. Pingback: Skrota bil Göteborg

  29. Pingback: http://boinc.umiacs.umd.edu/team_display.php?teamid=112577

  30. Pingback: portable

  31. Pingback: http://user1483520482162.fo.ru/wiki/376800_/5637916_Pou+infinito+Are+Here+To+Help+You+Out

  32. Pingback: motor club of america

  33. Pingback: economics tuition singapore

  34. Pingback: is motor club america a scam

  35. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  36. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  37. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  38. Pingback: Best Best Online News in the World

  39. Pingback: Einfach passives Einkommen

  40. Pingback: Switch Energy Supplier

  41. Pingback: Best Online News

  42. Pingback: TS Escorts

  43. Pingback: eau de merveilles de hermes

  44. Pingback: ceinture hermes

  45. Pingback: ugg sale boots

  46. Pingback: prada online

  47. Pingback: chanel bags store

  48. Pingback: vibram five fingers sale womens

  49. Pingback: louis vuitton outlet usa

  50. Pingback: cheap ugg sale

  51. Pingback: north face outlet online

  52. Pingback: Cheap Ecco shoes

  53. Pingback: roger vivier new york store

  54. Pingback: ugg boots outlet online

  55. Pingback: moncler sale outlet

  56. Pingback: roberto cavalli shop online

  57. Pingback: where to buy a barbour jacket

  58. Pingback: sergio rossi heels

  59. Pingback: north face backpack sale

  60. Pingback: cole haan sale shoes

  61. Pingback: the ugg store

  62. Pingback: chanel bags sale

  63. Pingback: nfl jerseys outlet

  64. Pingback: jimmy choo sale uk

  65. Pingback: michael kors shoes

  66. Pingback: cole haan outlet boots

  67. Pingback: jackets on sale canada

  68. Pingback: valeur action hermes

  69. Pingback: cheap mammut

  70. Pingback: bracelet hermes femme

  71. Pingback: Callaway Golf outlet online

  72. Pingback: michael kors coupon 2016

  73. Pingback: patagonia discount code

  74. Pingback: dkny outlet online

  75. Pingback: Christian Louboutin outlet online

  76. Pingback: ray bab

  77. Pingback: fake id generator

  78. Pingback: rene caovilla harrods

  79. Pingback: fake id proof of age

  80. Pingback: oakleyt

  81. Pingback: fake id templates

  82. Pingback: occhiali ray ban in offerta

  83. Pingback: prada wallets on sale

  84. Pingback: Roberto Cavalli on sale

  85. Pingback: Occhiali da sole Uomo e Donna Outlet Italia

  86. Pingback: ray ban occhiali da sole a goccia

  87. Pingback: coach - outlet online

  88. Pingback: nearest hermes store

  89. Pingback: montre arceau hermes femme

  90. Pingback: balmain jeans womens cheap

  91. Pingback: canada goose jackets online

  92. Pingback: buy fake id

  93. Pingback: florida fake id

  94. Pingback: canada goose on sale

  95. Pingback: hunter boots for sale

  96. Pingback: victoria secret store finder

  97. Pingback: adidas originals us

  98. Pingback: patagonia clothing store

  99. Pingback: Callaway Golf for sale

  100. Pingback: fake id usa

  101. Pingback: emu boots store

  102. Pingback: Pierre Hardy on sale

  103. Pingback: cheap arcteryx jackets

  104. Pingback: arcteryx jackets store

  105. Pingback: parajumpers online store

  106. Pingback: hermes parcel store

  107. Pingback: what is motor club america about

  108. Pingback: lk bennett shoes outlet uk

  109. Pingback: oakley store online

  110. Pingback: Louis Vuitton Outlet Online

  111. Pingback: buy NorthDakota fake id

  112. Pingback: emu boots online

  113. Pingback: ray ban outlet

  114. Pingback: ray ban outlet

  115. Pingback: ray ban outlet

  116. Pingback: cheap oakley radarlock

  117. Pingback: ray ban uk cheap

  118. Pingback: really cheap ray bans

  119. Pingback: golden goose 2017

  120. Pingback: Create a fake id

  121. Pingback: fake school id

  122. Pingback: fake student id

  123. Pingback: fake id consequences Minnesota

  124. Pingback: fake Wisconsin id generator

  125. Pingback: fake id miami

  126. Pingback: fake id consequences Wisconsin

  127. Pingback: cheap ray ban store

  128. Pingback: Oregon fake id template

  129. Pingback: Air max pas cher

  130. Pingback: Air max pas cher

  131. Pingback: Air max pas cher

  132. Pingback: Air max pas cher

  133. Pingback: generate fake id

  134. Pingback: fake id online

  135. Pingback: fake Pennsylvania can

  136. Pingback: making fake id

  137. Pingback: create drivers license online

  138. Pingback: canadian fake id online

  139. Pingback: Kansas fake id laws

  140. Pingback: fake Oregon id card

  141. Pingback: fake id god

  142. Pingback: buy Delaware fake id

  143. Pingback: ohio fake id laws

  144. Pingback: sac imitation hermes

  145. Pingback: Vibro plates in Rathnew

  146. Pingback: M&M Waterproofing Brisbane

  147. Pingback: sneakers golden goose

  148. Pingback: LUDDINI

  149. Pingback: Rothar Locations

  150. Pingback: Services

  151. Pingback: Medjugorje

  152. Pingback: DH Ryan Architects

  153. Pingback: achat sac hermes

  154. Pingback: basket golden goose

  155. Pingback: hermes chocolat

  156. Pingback: golden goose homme

  157. Pingback: sacs hermes birkin

  158. Pingback: boutique hermes toulouse

  159. Pingback: ceinture hermes

  160. Pingback: basket golden goose femme

  161. Pingback: hermes en france

  162. Pingback: golden goose sac

Leave a Reply